VCF renewals ▲ 31.4% YoY· Symantec EDR true ups ▲ 18%· Carbon Black avg quote uplift +22%· Mainframe MIPS capacity squeezes ▲· Audit notices ▲ 47% QoQ· Our last 10 deals avg −41% on quote· VCF renewals ▲ 31.4% YoY· Symantec EDR true ups ▲ 18%· Carbon Black avg quote uplift +22%· Mainframe MIPS capacity squeezes ▲· Audit notices ▲ 47% QoQ· Our last 10 deals avg −41% on quote
Wednesday · 27 May · MMXXVIIssue II
Independent · Buyer SideLive
Broadcom Negotiations
VMware · Symantec · CA · Carbon Black · Mainframe · Brocade The buyer's report on Broadcom contract economics. Not affiliated with Broadcom Inc.
VMware

What public sector enterprises actually paid for VCF subscription renewals in North America.

Nine public sector VCF subscription renewals closed in North America between October 2024 and April 2026. The median all in cost cleared at $2,640 per core per year, with a discount band of 38 percent against the seller's published rate. The procurement constraints in this cohort produced a tighter outcome distribution than the commercial cohort the Desk publishes alongside it.

Public sector VCF renewals in North America carry constraints that the commercial cohort does not. The procurement teams operate under acquisition regulations that prescribe how the renewal is competed, what the contract vehicle is, and how the price is documented in the award. The buyers cannot use migration threats freely because the acquisition file has to support the procurement choice on the record. The seller knows the constraints and prices accordingly. The Desk's view is that the public sector cohort produces a tighter clearing band than the commercial cohort and a slightly higher median per core cost, but a more predictable corridor around the median. The benchmark below covers nine renewals closed between October 2024 and April 2026. None of the buyers are named. All numbers are validated against signed contracts.

The cohort definition

The cohort is nine VCF subscription renewals across federal civilian agencies (4 of 9), federal defence adjacent contractors operating on government estates (3 of 9), and state government entities (2 of 9). The estate sizes range from 3,800 cores to 19,400 cores, with a median of 9,600 cores. All renewals are subscription, not perpetual. All include Aria Operations at the medium or high telemetry tier because the operational compliance posture requires the telemetry surface. All include vSAN. All are contracted on either a federal contract vehicle or a state cooperative purchasing vehicle, which constrains the published per core rate but does not constrain the bundle composition or the term structure.

The headline benchmark

The headline all in annual VCF subscription cost at close, normalised against the core count, runs between $2,310 and $3,050 per core per year. The median lands at $2,640 per core per year. The 25th percentile is $2,480. The 75th percentile is $2,820. The distribution is materially tighter than the EMEA financial services cohort the Desk published earlier in the quarter, with a range of roughly $740 per core per year against the EMEA cohort range of $1,700. The variance inside the cohort is driven by the contract vehicle used, the Aria telemetry tier, and the term length. The contract vehicle is the dominant variable. Renewals contracted on a federal civilian vehicle cleared 4 to 7 percent below renewals contracted on a defence adjacent vehicle, and 8 to 11 percent below renewals contracted on a state cooperative vehicle.

The composition of the per core number

The $2,640 median per core per year breaks into three lines. The VCF subscription core line accounts for roughly 61 percent of the total, or $1,610 per core per year. The Aria Operations line at the medium telemetry tier accounts for roughly 24 percent, or $635 per core per year, with the share rising to 28 percent for the renewals that carried the high telemetry tier. The vSAN line accounts for roughly 15 percent, or $395 per core per year. The composition is slightly Aria heavy against the commercial cohort because the public sector telemetry requirements push more renewals into the medium and high tiers.

"Public sector procurement is more constrained than commercial procurement, but the constraints cut both ways. The seller cannot price as widely against the cohort, and the buyer cannot wander as freely. The result is a tighter distribution around a slightly higher median."Public Sector Lead, The Desk

The discount band against the central published rate

The discount band the cohort clears at, against the central published rate sheet the seller maintains for commercial renewals, runs between 28 percent and 44 percent. The median clearing discount is 38 percent, which sits 5 percentage points below the EMEA financial services cohort median. The compression against the commercial cohort is driven primarily by the absence of free migration threats. Buyers in this cohort cannot meaningfully threaten to migrate inside the renewal cycle because the procurement vehicle does not support the threat as a record of the negotiation. The seller knows this and reduces the discount band accordingly. Two of the nine renewals carried a documented portfolio review across the prior contract period, which produced a discount band 4 to 6 percentage points above the cohort median because the review constituted a record of the buyer's posture that the seller had to respond to.

The escalator band

The renewal escalator across the cohort ran between 3 and 6 percent annually, with a median of 4 percent. The escalator band is narrower than the commercial cohort, again because the contract vehicles constrain the seller's escalator clauses to a documented range. Five year commits ran lower escalators than three year commits, with median escalators of 3.5 percent against 4.5 percent.

Public sector VCF subscription renewals in North America9
Median all in cost per core per year$2,640
Range across the cohort$2,310 to $3,050
Median clearing discount against published rate38%
Median escalator inside the term4%

What we have seen on live deals this quarter

A federal civilian agency closed a five year VCF subscription in March 2026 against an estate of 11,800 cores. The renewal cleared at $2,490 per core per year, slightly below the cohort median, on a federal civilian contract vehicle. The buyer arrived with a documented portfolio review across the prior term and a treasury posture that allowed for a 36 month prepayment inside the federal acquisition rules. The cumulative five year value landed at roughly $147M, against an opening quote that implied $194M. The procurement team's read against the cohort benchmark was that the close sat 6 percent below the cohort median for the five year band, which was the team's target band entering the negotiation. A state government entity closed a three year commit against a smaller estate of 5,200 cores on a state cooperative vehicle. The renewal cleared at $2,890 per core per year, slightly above the cohort median for the three year band. The buyer did not have a documented portfolio review and accepted a higher cost on the contract vehicle premium.

The takeaway

  • Public sector VCF subscription renewals in North America cleared at a median all in cost of $2,640 per core per year across the period. The range across the cohort is $2,310 to $3,050, which is materially tighter than the commercial cohort range.
  • The median clearing discount against the seller's published rate is 38 percent, which is 5 percentage points below the EMEA financial services cohort. The compression is driven by the absence of free migration threats inside the procurement vehicle.
  • The two renewals that cleared above the cohort median both carried a documented portfolio review across the prior contract period. The review constituted a record of the buyer's posture that the seller had to respond to, and produced 4 to 6 percentage points of additional discount.
Reading a public sector VCF renewal on a federal or state vehicle? Write to the Desk → Two analyst calls, no pitch.

Three related articles

Cross references. Service: Benchmarking. Practice: VCF Renewal. Calculator: VCF core calculator.
Correspondence Invited

Write before the quote becomes a position.

Two analyst calls. No pitch. We tell you what we would do, what the leverage actually is, and whether we are the right firm. If we are not, we will say so.
Who we work for. Buyer side only. No reseller relationship with Broadcom. No partnership of any kind. We do not earn anything from products sold or renewed. Only from outcomes delivered against the contract.